The following blog post is taken from a sermon I did two years ago. Now, in the wake of the most recent rape and minimal sentence, it speaks loudly.
A link to a podcast of the sermon is here: http://www.lcuuc.org/recordings/2013-14/2014-01-05_Shaw_Rape_SERMON.mp3 There are minor differences between the live performance and the written version below.
A link to a podcast of the sermon is here: http://www.lcuuc.org/recordings/2013-14/2014-01-05_Shaw_Rape_SERMON.mp3 There are minor differences between the live performance and the written version below.
In January of
last year, a picture of a female rape protester was suddenly everywhere on the
internet. The picture showed a young woman wearing no shirt, and a low cut
skirt, with the words “Still not asking for it,” written across her torso. Her
fist was raised above her head. A male viewer commented, ‘but then again, its
kind like putting a meat suit on and telling a shark not to eat you’.
The male website
owner from one site responded with a brilliant and pointed reply:
We men are not sharks!
We are not rabid
animals living off of pure instinct.
We are capable of
rational thinking and understanding.
Just because
someone is cooking food doesn’t mean you’re entitled to eat it.
Just because a
banker is counting money doesn’t mean you’re being given free money.
Just because a
person is naked doesn’t mean you’re entitled to have sex with them.
You are not
entitled to someone else’s body just because it’s exposed.
What is so
difficult about this concept?’
Indeed- what is
so very difficult about this concept?
What is difficult
is that we live in a rape culture.
“Culture”
is a nice sounding word. It can have connotations of patronage of the arts, or
a feel of worldly sophistication such as I myself am wont to display. If we
have “culture” or are “cultured” we have theoretically risen above the most
basic levels of civilization.
Culture,
however, is more than that. The Merriam Webster Dictionary says that culture is
also these two things:
“a.
behavior that depends upon the capacity for learning and transmitting knowledge
to succeeding generations
b:
the customary beliefs, social forms, and material traits of a racial,
religious, or social group; also: the characteristic features of everyday
existence (as diversions or a way of life} shared by people in a place or time
<popular culture> <southern culture>
Our
behaviors for sharing knowledge with succeeding generations, and our customary
beliefs, social forms and traits. The features of our everyday existence.
Culture
is the fire in which we burn. It is the air we breathe. It is all around us to
the point that we often don’t even see it.
So
why are we suddenly hearing that we are a “Rape Culture”? The phrase seems to
be popping up everywhere lately. Is this a new thing? Has something changed?
Are we really- and if so, how do we begin to change it?
Rape
culture is a concept used to describe a culture in which rape and sexual
violence are common and in which prevalent attitudes, norms, practices, and
media normalize, excuse, tolerate, or even condone rape. Before 1974 we didn’t
talk a lot about rape in America.
In
1974, the term rape culture was used in Rape: The First Sourcebook for Women.
It was one of the first books to include first-person accounts of rape, which
were one reason for rape entering the public view. In the book, the New York
Radical Feminists stated that "our ultimate goal is to eliminate rape and
that goal cannot be achieved without a revolutionary transformation of our
society."
Things
have changed since 1974, and not always in ways that we could control or easily
understand.
We’ve
traditionally talked about rape as an act of power, oppression, domination, and
control, rather than sex, and this is still true. But why now, why in today’s
culture, is it seeming to hit the news every few weeks?
We
seem to be barraged with stories of teachers sleeping with middle and high
school students. 50 Shades of Grey, a book about a sexually power dysfunctional
relationship, made the New York Times Best-Seller list and is considered romantic.
In
August of 2012, a drunk and unconscious 16 year-old West Virginia girl was
raped at a party by two teenaged boys, both football players on the
Steubenville, Ohio high school team. The boys not only did not try to hide what
they were doing, but they took pictures, and texted them to friends. Their
arrests shocked them, and their friends, and their convictions rocked the
country and tore their town into fighting factions. CNN coverage mentioned how
these boy’s lives were ruined…
Laurie
Anderson, author of the book “Speak” which tells the story of a fictional
teenaged rape victim, is afraid that young boys don’t understand what rape
actually is. On her website there is a discussion board, where real teachers
talk about students’ reactions to the book. One middle school teacher from
California posted at length about her shock and dismay as she realized that the
children she taught, gifted 8th graders, couldn’t understand why
Steubenville was rape- they got the idea that it was rape if the victim said
no, but no one had said no there. The victim was unconscious.
When
she explained to them that rape wasn’t just being forced to have sexual contact
after saying no, rape was sexual contact that happened when the victim didn’t
say “yes, what a great idea!” the young people in her class were horrified. Two
of the boys even approached her after the class, to ask about specific events
they themselves had participated in.
By
creating a fiction of stranger danger, the rapist as a faceless shadow taking
out his anger on a random victim, the US has otherized and monsterized all
rapists in a way that simply isn’t true. 1 in 4 women and 1 in 6 men will
experience sexual assault, and most of their attackers will be someone they
know. And in some cases, the rapist will not even realize that what he (and I
am using male pronouns only because statistically the vast majority of
perpetrators are male) did was rape.
Rape
Culture.
Professor
Steven Landsburg is an economics instructor at the University of Rochester. He
was recently elected professor of the year there by students. His March 20th
2013 public blog wondered:
“Let's
suppose that you, or I, or someone we love, or someone we care about from afar,
is raped while unconscious in a way that causes no direct physical harm—no
injury, no pregnancy, no disease transmission. Despite the lack of physical
damage, we are shocked, appalled and horrified at the thought of being treated
in this way, and suffer deep trauma as a result. Ought the law discourage such
acts of rape? Should they be illegal?”
A
few paragraphs later he says:
“As
long as I'm safely unconscious and therefore shielded from the costs of an
assault, why shouldn't the rest of the world (or more specifically my
attackers) be allowed to reap the benefits?”
Two
students who read the blog complained. Not 30, or 60, or all of them. Two.
Rape
Culture.
How
can the worth and dignity of each individual be upheld, if they are a commodity
which exists so that others can reap the benefits? Where is the compassion, the
peace, the respect for connection?
Our
media commercial culture doesn’t help much. We have swung from the sexist and
often misogynistic commercials of the 50’s which showed things like a woman
being spanked by her husband for giving him stale coffee, and another wife in
awe of a ketchup bottle which even a woman can open, to modern day portrayals
of men as endearingly stupid, lazy, animalistic, or aggressive. You may have
seen the yogurt commercial in which a bumbling husband overhears his wife
talking about her diet, including “apple turn-over, Boston Cream Pie, chocolate
strawberry..” We watch as he creeps behind her back, rooting in the fridge for
all the good things she has presumably kept him from gorging on, blindly
ignoring the Yoplait yogurt containers which she is actually referring to.
Pizza and cleaning supply commercials where husbands and their friends nearly
destroy a room, and are surprised when the wife or girlfriend is upset.
Tostitos spots where businessmen stuff snacks in their faces while the female
member of the team works, then hi-five one another as she finishes the project,
yelling “Go team.”
Lynx
and Axe Body Wash products and sprays for men are apparently geared toward a
group of people almost unable to function independently, and recent fast food
commercials have included men ramming one another at the drive through window,
unable to wait, men unable to share, and men taking one another, and their
girlfriend’s food or drinks because they cannot control themselves.
No
one bases their life off of commercials, but they reflect what amuses us,
charms us, calls to us. They are insidious. They are a mirror. And the
reflection is ugly.
The
web itself furthers the problem. Social networks make many lives open books. Young
people are growing up in a world of continuous connection, continuous check-in,
and continuous bombardment with information from around the world. And quite a
bit of that information furthers the devaluation of others, or casting others
as a benefit to be reaped as we search for fun and entertainment.
Just
while researching and writing this sermon I found literally thousands of
websites dedicated to or filled with “pranks,” typically done by younger men
and women and filmed for immediate net posting. Pranks like feeding someone a ghost
chili on their pizza, and watching, laughing as they screamed in pain. I saw
versions of this not once or twice, but hundreds of times. Pranks like flipping
someone’s bed up to wake them- launching them face first into a wall. Pranks
like covering a passed-out young man’s face with black permanent marker
drawings of genitals and obscenities, at a party celebrating his wedding the
next day, or his starting a new professional job in the morning. These pranks
are not done to enemies, but to supposed friends.
Friends
who the college professor I mentioned might say are there for us to reap the
benefit.
Rape
Culture- a culture where others, men and women, are there to provide us with
something. They somehow owe us amusement, sex, validation, entertainment. Among
those under 30 women seem to suffer most from the sexual expectations, while
young men are beaten, battered, and demeaned by vicious assaults masquerading
as fun.
As
Unitarian Universalists, how are we called to stop this? How do we dismantle a
culture where others exist for enjoyment, regardless of the damage?
We
begin at the grassroots level, doing what we do best.
We
talk and we teach. We live our values in the real world, and we call for
transformation.
Talk
to your children, your grandchildren, your friends. When you talk about things
like Steubenville, make sure that there is understanding of what rape is; that
it is sexual contact without a firm yes, not contact that continues after a no.
Ask
if they agree with this.
Talk
about using others for personal gratification or entertainment. Explain why any
act, any act at all, that uses another person’s body in ways they do not enjoy,
for someone else’s entertainment, is wrong. Ask your children and grandchildren
about bullying and pranking, find out what they think is funny, and what they
find dismaying.
Find
out why they feel that way.
When
products or services are sold to you using objectionable commercials that
violate your beliefs, you don’t have to boycott the product. But take 5 minutes
and send an email to the company. Let them know you are buying in spite of the
commercial, not because of it.
And
talk to others about why you feel the way you do.
We
cannot dismantle our rape culture by continuing to do what we are doing- by
teaching women how not to be raped. This supposes that rapists are those
strangers lurking in dark alleys and something worse- that women alone are
responsible for preventing rape. That somehow something women do or don’t do
causes them to be raped.
During
the Occupy Wall Street protests, several sexual assaults of protesters
occurred. In response, Occupy Wall Street created a 16-square-foot “safe
house,” designed to shelter up to 30 women.
This was a good thing, but it didn’t seek out the root of the problem.
According
to feminist activist, Deanna Zandt, “getting the men not to rape [the women]”
is a better starting point. I agree
absolutely. Columnist, Katha Pollitt, put all of this in perspective when she
recently asked, “Can you imagine hetero MEN having to set up a safe space to
protect them from women and LGBT?” No.
Most of us can’t. Too many of us
have been wired to see men as predators and women as princesses needing
protection, the latter of which doesn’t always have a happy-ending. Something’s got to give.
Women
need safe spaces because we live in a rape culture that makes sexual occupancy
permissible anywhere. Destruction of the
latter needs to happen yesterday—as a requirement of human dignity. Economic and gender justice go hand in
hand. While Occupying Wall Street and
other locales, Occupy Rape Culture simultaneously. Doing otherwise is like
throwing women to the lions, and trying to teach them not to be eaten.
A
Michigan mother and blogger named Magda Pecsenye demonstrated how to talk to
very young men about the issue in a letter she wrote to her sons, age 8 and 11,
and posted on her blog here. In it she stresses the importance of getting consent,
happy consent, to have sex, and being kind and respectful to a partner, and
then she says this:
This letter is almost over but this next part is
super-important: Not everyone you know has been taught all the stuff we’ve
talked about. You are going to know people, and maybe even be friends with
people, who think it’s ok to hurt other people in a lot of ways. One of those ways
is sex. I know you’re going to hear other boys say things about girls, or
sometimes about other boys, that means they don’t care about those girls’
feelings or bodies. When you do, I need you to step in. All you have to do is
say something like, “Dude, that’s not cool” or something that lets the person
saying something nasty know that it’s not ok. Remember that everyone wants to
fit in. If you can take control of the mood in the room by letting them know
nasty talk isn’t ok, they’ll stop so they don’t look like an idiot.
Remember how we talk all the time about how we’re the
people who help, who fix things when there’s a problem or someone’s in trouble?
You may get the chance to do that someday. Because those boys who say nasty
things about girls may actually do something to those girls. If you are ever
anywhere where boys start hurting a girl, or touching her in any way that she
doesn’t want, you need to step in. If she’s asleep or drunk or passed out or
drugged and can’t say “no,” you need to step in. Remember, it’s not good unless
both people can say they want it. If a girl isn’t saying anything, that doesn’t
mean she wants it. If she isn’t saying specifically that she wants it, then
it’s wrong.
She
continues to tell them how to safely step in, and that even if they hate the
girl, even if she has been mean to them, to still stand up for her, that they
can hate her again tomorrow.
We
can destroy this rape culture.
We
can talk with our children and grandchildren. We can talk with our friends and
co-workers. We can create a culture where treating people as things to be used
isn’t acceptable, whether we are talking about rape, or vicious pranks. We can
make it clear that men are not bumbling mindless animals, too aggressive or
brainless to be taught how to control themselves.
Simply
live your values. And share them as you journey. Refuse to join a culture where
doing otherwise is accepted. When enough of us stand together in fighting for
dignity and worth, compassion, and understanding, we become the majority.
We
change the world.
Amen.
Copyright 2013 Reverend Amy Petrie Shaw. May be reprinted with attribution.
Copyright 2013 Reverend Amy Petrie Shaw. May be reprinted with attribution.
No comments:
Post a Comment